An extrinsic is a piece of information that comes from outside the chain and is included in a block. Extrinsics fall into three categories: inherents, signed transactions, and unsigned transactions.
Note that events are not extrinsics. The chain emits events for pieces of information that are intrinsic to the chain itself. For example, staking rewards are events, not extrinsics, because the reward is triggered by circumstances intrinsic to the chain's logic.
A block in Substrate is composed of a header and an array of extrinsics. The header contains a
block height, parent hash, extrinsics root, state root, and digest. This section will only focus on the extrinsics root.
Extrinsics are bundled together into a block as a series to be executed as each is defined in the runtime. The extrinsics root is a cryptographic digest of this series. This serves two purposes. First, it prevents any alterations to the series of extrinsics after the header has been built and distributed. Second, it provides a means of allowing light clients to succinctly verify that any given extrinsic did indeed exist in a block given only knowledge of the header.
Inherents are pieces of information that are not signed and only inserted into a block by the block author. They are not gossiped on the network or stored in the transaction queue. There is nothing technically preventing a Substrate chain that gossips inherents, but there would be no fee-based spam prevention mechanism.
Inherents represent data that, in an opinionated fashion, describes one of a number of valid pieces of information. They are assumed to be "true" simply because a sufficiently large number of validators have agreed on them being reasonable.
For example, the author of the block may insert a timestamp inherent into the block. There is no way to prove that a timestamp is true the way the desire to send funds is proved with a signature. Rather, validators accept or reject the block based on how reasonable the other validators find the timestamp, which may mean it is within some acceptable range of their own system clocks.
Signed transactions contain a signature of the account that issued the transaction and stands to pay a fee to have the transaction included on chain. Because the value of including signed transactions on-chain can be recognized prior to execution, they can be gossiped on the network between nodes with a low risk of spam.
Signed transactions fit the concept of a transaction in Ethereum or Bitcoin.
Some cases call for unsigned transactions. Use unsigned transactions with care, as their validation logic can be difficult.
Since the transaction is not signed, there is nobody to pay a fee. Because of this, the transaction queue lacks economic logic to prevent spam. Unsigned transactions also lack a nonce, making replay protection difficult. A few transactions warrant using the unsigned variant, but they will require some form of spam prevention based on a custom implementation of signed extension, which can exist on unsigned transactions.
An example of unsigned transactions in Substrate is the I'm Online heartbeat transaction sent by authorities. The transaction includes a signature from a Session key, which does not control funds and therefore cannot pay a fee. The transaction pool controls spam by checking if a heartbeat has already been submitted in the session.
SignedExtension is a trait by which a transaction can be extended with additional data or logic.
Signed extensions are used anywhere you want some information about a transaction prior to
execution. This is heavily used in the transaction queue.
The runtime can use some of this data, for example the
Call that will be dispatched, to calculate
transaction fees. Signed extensions also include an
AdditionalSigned type that can hold any
encodable data, and therefore allow you to perform any custom logic prior to including or
dispatching a transaction. The transaction queue regularly calls functions from
validate transactions prior to block construction to avoid including transactions that will fail in
Despite the name,
SignedExtension can also be used to verify unsigned transactions. The
*_unsigned set of methods can be implemented to encapsulate validation, spam, and replay
protection logic that is needed by the transaction pool.